Is the Lottery a Tax on the Poor?

A lottery is a competition based on chance, in which numbered tickets are sold and prizes awarded to the holders of numbers drawn at random. It is a popular means of raising money for the state, and is also used as a form of gambling.

It’s an alluring idea: a few bucks for a chance to fantasize about winning millions. For some, that’s all it is, but for others—especially those with the lowest incomes—lottery play can become a major budget drain. And for that reason, critics say lotteries are a disguised tax on those least able to afford it.

The word lottery comes from the Dutch noun lotte, meaning “fate” or “luck.” It is thought to be a calque on Middle Dutch loterie, which itself is believed to be a calque on Latin literae fertum, literally “the writing of lots.” The term was first used to describe a lottery in England in 1569.

Lottery is often seen as a way for states to raise revenue without increasing taxes or cutting essential services. And indeed, it has been a successful tool for many governments, particularly during times of economic stress. But there’s a lot more to lottery than just money: it is, at heart, a way of selling dreams of instant wealth.

There are two main issues with the way lottery operates in the United States: its structure and its marketing. On the structure side, it’s a classic case of public policy being made piecemeal and incrementally, with little overall oversight. The state sets up a monopoly for itself; establishes an agency or public corporation to run it; starts with a modest number of relatively simple games; and then, under constant pressure for additional revenues, progressively expands the number of games and the amount of money that can be won on each.

This expansion and growth has been fueled by the lottery’s popularity, and the fact that people like to gamble. It is estimated that more than 60% of adults play lottery games. But it’s also true that people don’t necessarily buy tickets because they are compulsive gamblers. Instead, they do so in order to fantasize about what they would do if they won the jackpot.

And there’s no doubt that the marketing of lottery games plays into this inextricable human impulse. Billboards announcing massive jackpots dangle the promise of a new life, and the media is full of stories about people who have won big. All this marketing creates a sense that the lottery is not only fair, but a good thing to do. In addition to this, lottery advertising is frequently deceptive, presenting misleading information about odds and inflating the value of money won (lottery jackpots are paid out in annuity payments over three decades, with inflation dramatically eroding the current value). All this serves to keep the public addicted to gambling. This addiction isn’t just bad for the economy, but it’s a huge problem for society as well.